Looking for the best non-candy Easter egg fillers to make this year’s Easter egg hunt extra fun without the sugar rush? Whether you're stuffing Easter eggs for toddlers, kids, or tweens, this list of more than 100 creative Easter egg filler ideas has something for everyone! From tiny toys and mini games to stickers, keychains, and DIY surprises, these unique Easter egg stuffers will keep kids excited long after the hunt is over. I’ve split them into gender-neutral Easter egg fillers, Easter egg surprises for boys, and Easter egg goodies for girls to make your planning even easier. Get ready to fill your Easter baskets with fun, candy-free treasures that kids will love!
#1 The top one on my list is money...probably the easiest too.
I've been doing this for my children since they could find the eggs and understood money. I put pennies all the way to bills. The higher the bill, the harder it is to find. To keep it fair, I have also chose to do the same amount for each kid. I put their initial on an egg to let the other kids know it's not theirs. I've also done color coded eggs in the past. One kid would get one color, the other a different one. This works well if you have both girls and boys with the list below. Let one color be a free for all. I usually do all the coins in the free for all easter egg color. But, of course, it's up to you! I grew up being SOL most of the time with the money eggs because my brothers always found the hard to reach eggs that had the $20 bills in them :)
Now for the other ideas! I've included pictures below from popular stores I visited to give you some ideas. Then at the bottom of the pictures are full on lists for boys, girls, and more neutral themed easter egg stuffer ideas. Tell me in the comments what's your favorite thing to add to easter eggs!
Easter Egg Stuff Ideas Hobby Lobby:
Although at most craft type stores, you'll be able to find some non-candy things that can be stuffed into an easter egg, it's important to go beyond the seasonal decor and just hit the rest of the store!
Easter Egg Filler Ideas from Target:
Easter Egg Stuff Ideas from Michaels:
Non-Candy Easter Egg Filler Ideas From Amazon
(click images to go to link)
50 Gender-Neutral Easter Egg Fillers
These ideas work for any child and add a fun twist to your Easter egg hunt!
- Mini LEGO pieces
- Temporary tattoos
- Mini erasers
- Stickers
- Glow-in-the-dark stars
- Coins (quarters, dimes, nickels)
- Tiny toy animals
- Jokes written on paper
- Silly putty
- Beaded bracelets
- Finger puppets
- Bouncy balls
- Keychains
- Mini puzzles
- Glow sticks
- Fun shoelaces
- Rubber stamps
- Slinky springs
- Marbles
- Water beads
- Bubble wrap squares (for popping fun!)
- Small bells
- Mini magnifying glasses
- Confetti poppers
- Friendship bracelets
- Finger skateboards
- Press-on nail decals
- Wooden coins with fun activities (e.g., “Extra 10 mins of bedtime story”)
- Mini slime containers
- Funny face stickers
- Alphabet beads
- Small whistles
- Mini compass
- Lip balm
- Colorful shoelaces
- Sticky hands
- Origami animals
- Play foam
- Washi tape rolls
- Magic growing capsules (expand in water)
- Finger flashlights
- Scented erasers
- DIY scratch-off cards
- Pocket-sized maze games
- Mini harmonicas
- DIY coupon (e.g., “Stay up 15 minutes later”)
- Fake mustaches
- Mini spirographs
- Stress balls
- Tiny containers of kinetic sand
25 Boy-Themed Easter Egg Fillers
These ideas are great for boys who love adventure, action, and creativity!
- Mini cars (Hot Wheels or Matchbox)
- Mini dinosaurs
- Army men figurines
- Superhero stickers
- Mini yo-yos
- Foam dart bullets
- Mini parachute men
- Plastic bugs or snakes
- Sports-themed keychains
- Finger rockets
- Comic strip clippings
- Mini squirt guns
- Toy handcuffs
- Compass ring
- Toy robots
- Rubber band bracelets
- Mini ninja figures
- Shark tooth necklace
- Glow-in-the-dark army men
- Plastic construction tools
- Pirate coins
- Light-up rings
- DIY treasure map scroll
- Small slingshots
- Stick-on mustaches
25 Girl-Themed Easter Egg Fillers
These are perfect for girls who love cute and creative surprises!
- Mini nail polish bottles
- Hair clips and bows
- Sparkly rings
- Barbie shoes or accessories
- Mini dolls
- Stick-on earrings
- Lip gloss
- Miniature perfume samples
- Cute washi tape
- Tiny notebooks
- Little charm pendants
- DIY friendship bracelet kits
- Clip-on earrings
- Pastel-colored slime
- Unicorn erasers
- Beaded keychains
- Miniature animal figurines
- Fairy tale stickers
- Tiny bottles of glitter
- DIY bead necklaces
- Hair scrunchies
- Floral temporary tattoos
- Miniature fairy doors
- Press-on nails
- Mini sewing kits
My non-candy easter egg stuffers this year...so far.
Apparently I should have bought some of those items when I took pictures of them! I didn't realize how I needed more :) Another good place to get easter egg stuffers is 5 Below and Ulta.
These below are magnetic bookmarks. My kids love to read, so these are perfect!
The stickers linked above in the Amazon section.
These are linked above as well in Amazon section.
This jewelry was from Wal-Mart.
These below are magnetic bookmarks. My kids love to read, so these are perfect!
Pin for later:
Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
0 comments